"Which is worse? The wolf who cries before eating the lamb or the wolf who does not."— Leo Tolstoy

Showing posts with label 2012 ELECTIONS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2012 ELECTIONS. Show all posts

Friday, December 30, 2011

The Most Important But Ignored Domestic News Story of 2011: The Resignation of Alan Bersin

NOTE: This is the first of a series of articles on the Department of Homeland Security.

NEW YORK  - DECEMBER 30, 2011 -Today was Alan Bersin's last day of work. Tomorrow he will join the millions of unemployed Americans who will be looking for a new job during 2012. Who is Alan Bersin?  The fact that so few people have heard of Alan Bersin is convincing evidence that the major media outlets  have ignored important negative news stories on the Administration of President Barack Obama.

Bersin, who was appointed as acting Commissioner of Border and Customs Protection through a recess appointment by President Obama, was forced to resign from his job after the U.S. Senate Finance Committee refused to act on his nominationt. When Bersin's resignation was reported by The Hill earlier this month, angry online comments attributed his resignation to political obstruction by the Republicans on the Committee. The real reason for the failure of his appointment was the fact that he had been accused of lying to the Committee in the background forms all nominees are required to submit when seeking a political appointment to an executive branch agency. 

Specifically, Bersin informed the Committee that he and his wife had employed three domestic employees. A due diligence investigation by Committee investigators disclosed that the couple had actually employed ten domestic employees during the relevant reporting period. While Bersin certainly has less reason to remember his domestic employees than former California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, it is unusual for someone to not remember seven employees no matter how self absorbed that person may be. Perhaps the reason for Bersin's selective memory was the fact that he and his wife failed to file the I-9 forms - required by Federal law - which verify eligibility for legal employment. Bersin is a Harvard and Yale educated Rhodes Scholar and former U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of California.  His wife is a sitting San Diego County Superior Court Judge. The issue of his failure to file I-9 forms for employees was raised when he was nominated to be a U.S. Attorney by President Clinton in 1993.

The best defense Bersin could muster during his confirmation hearings was that he had complied with the "Spirit of the Law."  It is not surprising that the senators responsible for consenting to the confirmation of the Administration's proposed Border chief found this explanation less than adequate.


Border enforcement and security is one of the most high profile and important domestic policy issues facing our country as we move into a presidential election year. Yet no major newspaper or broadcast media outlet bothered to conducted an investigation into Bersin's recess appointment and subsequent performance in office. Aside from theSan DiegoReader a few bloggers, conservative and lobbying  industry  websites,  this story barely registered a blip. The best the Washington Post could muster was publishing, on Christmas day, a brief AP story on Bersin's resignation.   

Far from being a silly and unimportant nanny inquisition, the questions raised by Bersin's recess appointment, his performance in office and his testimony before Congress speak volumes about the dysfunction of the Obama administration's brand of governing. It reflects a culture of making high-level appointments based on political utility rather than competency and integrity. It also reflects an arrogant practiceof fighting for and defending incompetent and ethically challenged officials in the face of clear evidence of wrongdoing, a practice that has ground the wheels of competent governing to a halt 

NOTE:  I will be updating this post with more information about Bersin's appointment, as well as his performance in office, so check bookmark the page and check back over the next few days.

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

The Measure of a President's Character - Part I - Abraham Lincoln

"Neither let us be slandered from our duty by false accusations against us, nor frightened from it by menaces of destruction to the Government, nor of dungeons to ourselves. Let us have faith that right makes might; and in that faith, let us, to the end, dare to do our duty, as we understand it." 
Abraham Lincoln, Speech on Slavery, Hartford, Connecticut, March 6, 1860


When I was in high school I started collecting books on the Civil War, slavery, and old newspapers from the period. I learned about Abraham Lincoln from the pages of Harper's Weekly, a contemporary chronicle of Lincoln's presidency, illustrated with large mythopoeic drawings by Thomas Nast, Winslow Homer and other artists of the era. Lincoln was portrayed as a larger than life figure who was sacrificed on the alter of freedom to save us from the sin of slavery.
"President Lincoln Entering Richmond"

One of the books I purchased then, which I still have, is a first edition of the Lincoln Douglas Debates printed in 1860. While reading the transcripts of the debates I noticed  that Lincoln tempered his anti-slavery comments in speeches he gave in Southern Illinois.  Later, I learned that Lincoln had  fired General George C. Fremont for refusing to rescind an emancipation  order  he issued in 1861 freeing slaves held in Missouri.  Lincoln's actions -  motivated by his unwillingness to jeopardize Missouri's membership in the Union - made it clear that his emancipation policy was motivated more by military exigencies than by a desire to end slavery.  Lincoln also sanctioned the arrest, imprisonment  and deportation of newspaper editors and local politicians who publicly expressed opposition to the war, and suspended the writ of habeas corpus, one of the most important of our Constitutional freedoms. Other Presidents, most notably Woodrow Wilson, have taken similar actions in time of war, and Franklin Roosevelt sanctioned the forced relocation to concentration camps  of Japanese citizens solely on the basis of their ethnicity.  I came to believe that their was nothing extraordinary about the moral character of President Lincoln.  He was like no different than any other president who was willing to compromise his principles if he believed it necessary, or even expedient for him to do so.  

The more I learned about him, the more I realized that Lincoln was not like any other politician.  I now believe that all other Presidents should be measured and judged by his conduct while in office.  Two little known events that occurred during the Civil War in the Fall and Winter of 1862-1863 define Lincoln's character and, in my view, raise him head and shoulders above other presidents who are considered great men, but who failed similar tests during their presidencies.

The Fall and Winter of 1862-1863 was a difficult time for President Lincoln and the Army of the Potomac.  In August, the Union forces had suffered a devastating defeat at the Second Battle of Bull Run.  The Confederate army almost succeeded in cutting off the Union Army from Washington, D.C., an event that would have forced the evacuation of the city.  In September, Confederate General "Stonewall" Jackson captured Harper's Ferry, in West Virginia, along with a garrison of Union soldiers and a stockpile of supplies. Three days later McClellan fought Lee to a draw at the Battle of Antietam in Maryland.  In early November,  Lincoln removed McLellan as the commander of Union forces.  He was replaced by General Burnside who marched the Union army into another defeat at the battle of Fredericksburgh during the second week in December. The ability of the Union army to defeat the Confederates was in doubt, and the naval intervention of foreign powers to break the blockade of Southern ports was still a threat.

On December 17, 1862, General Ulysses S. Grant issued General Orders No. 11, a directive  expelling all Jews from Kentucky, Tennessee, and Mississippi. General Orders No. 11 was motivated by Grant's frustration with Jewish peddlers whom he claimed ignored restrictions on travel and traded in black market cotton. The language of General Orders No. 11 was broad, and the army immediately started forcing Jews from their homes, in some cases giving families  no more than 24 hours to evacuate.   

At a time when the only thing standing between the Confederate army and Washington, D.C., was the good faith and skill of his generals, Lincoln didn't hesitate to countermand Grant's order.  On January 3rd, 1863, two days after the emancipation proclamation went into effect, Lincoln directed that General Orders No. 11 be immediately revoked.  President Lincoln explained that "he would allow no American to be wronged because of his religious affiliation."
 
During the months of August and September in 1862 an uprising of Dakota Sioux in Southwestern Minnesota lead to the deaths of approximately 500 settlers and soldiers.  The uprising was put down by U.S.  troops led by General Alexander Pope, who was sent west  after his stinging defeat at the Second Battle of Bull Run.  At the end of hostilities, the U.S. military held 2,000 Dakota men, women, and children as prisoners.  A military commission was established to try those Dakotas charged with murdering or raping settlers.  

The ongoing Dakota trials were brought to the attention of President Lincoln during a cabinet meeting on October 14th.  On October 17th General Pope informed the Commission that  "the President directs that no executions be made without his sanction."  In a matter of weeks, 398 Dakota men were tried by the Commission, all without the benefit of counsel.  The Commission convicted 328 of the Dakota defendants and ordered that 308 be hanged. Upon hearing of the verdicts, President Lincoln asked for "a full and complete record of [the] convictions" and "a careful statement" indicating "the more guilty and influential of the culprits."  On November 15, the records of the trials were forwarded to President Lincoln. Accompanying the records was a letter from General Pope urging the President to authorize the execution of all of the condemned.  Pope's letter warned of the danger of mob violence if the executions were not carried out immediately . 

With the outcome of the Civil War uncertain, and battles raging within a days horseback ride from Washington, D.C., President Lincoln took the time to review summaries of the trial records prepared by government lawyers and considered the fate of all 300 Dakota defendants still awaiting execution on the Northwestern frontier.  On December 4th, two days before President Lincoln's made his decision, soldiers surrounded and disarmed a lynch mob of several hundred settlers who had attacked the camp were the Dakota prisoners were being detained. On December 6th President Lincoln issued an order allowing only 39 of the planned 300 executions to go forward.


It would have been easy for Lincoln to not involve himself in these peripheral matters and delegate their resolution to a subordinate.  Instead, he believed that the ethnic cleansing of thousands of citizens, and the imminent execution of 300 potentially innocent Native Americans, were of such grave concern that they deserved the direct and full attention of the President of the United States; even during one of the most crucial and potentially dangerous periods of the Civil War.  For Abraham Lincoln - at least in these two instances - Due Process and the Rule of Law trumped even the exigencies of war.

Saturday, July 16, 2011

George W. Obama's Assassins | The Nation

500,000 individuals donated to Barack Obama's campaign during the last reporting cycle. Here's an example of the foreign policy their blood money is supporting:
"JSOC—and the Navy SEALs in particular—will become legendary in a much broader circle because of the bin Laden killing, but the secretive unit has had its share of controversy. JSOC forces were responsible for the October 8, 2010, botched rescue that ended up killing British aid worker Linda Norgrove in Afghanistan. JSOC also carried out a raid in Gardez, Afghanistan, in February 2010, during which five people, including two pregnant women and a US-trained Afghan police commander were killed. In that case, senior Afghan security officials and eyewitnesses claimed that US forces dug the bullets out of the women’s bodies. NATO had initially tried to cover up the incident, suggesting it may have been a Taliban “honor killing”; but eventually Admiral McRaven took responsibility for the botched raid and apologized to the family.

The primacy of JSOC within the administration’s foreign policy—from Yemen and Somalia to Afghanistan and Pakistan—indicates that Obama has doubled down on the Bush-era policy of targeted assassination as a staple of US foreign policy."
The Nation - May 23, 2011

Thursday, November 4, 2010

DESERT ZEITGEIST: 2010 ELECTION ANALYSIS

The most important development coming out of Tuesday's mid-term election results is that the conservative, HB1070 worshipping cabal of the Arizona Republican Party now has a veto-proof majority in both the Arizona House and the Arizona Senate.  They immediately flexed their muscles by electing Russell Pearce - the Godfather of the HB1070 anti-immigration movement - to be the  new President of the Arizona State Senate.  Everyone needs to brace themselves  for  two years of increasingly draconian budget cuts and more tax money being wasted on frivolous litigation defending indefensibly unconstitutional legislation relating to immigration.

All I can say is thank God for term limits, which appear to be the last best hope for idiot proofing Arizona government.  However, it increasingly looks as if term limits in Arizona politics is as fruitless an exercise as rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.    

In the coming days I will be reporting on the devastating impact that the last round of budget cuts has had on the poorest and most vulnerable of Arizona's citizens, and the irresponsible budget slashing we can expect from the legislature over the next two years.  Watch for an increase in the level of suffering among Arizona's poor, particularly poor children. Also watch for the 14th Amendment anchor-baby cloud to grow larger each month (more  later on the unintended consequences and dangerous implications of the  efforts to modify the 14th Amendment on Arizonans' Second Amendment rights). 

It is mind numbing how badly the Democratic Party misread the mood of the country leading up to this election, and how badly many pundits have misjudged the election results.  I was dumbfounded when I read John Fund's column in the Wall Street Journal last week which contained an interview with a retiring six-term democratic congressman who revealed that as late as September the Democratic leadership's pollsters were telling members of the democratic caucus that their constituents didn't care about the deficit.  Post election analysis by pollsters and pundits are equally tone deaf.  

My congressional district in Phoenix is the most heavily democratic district in the State and home  to Congressman for Life Ed Pastor, the only Democratic Congressman in Arizona that did not have a credible challenge in the general election this year.   My polling station in downtown Phoenix was like a ghost town.  I had to side step the tumbleweeds rolling past the empty voting booths.

ASU Pollster Bruce Merrill appeared tonight on PBS' local Horizon program and opined that the poor turnout by the democratic base was the result of the absence of President Obama on the ballot this election cycle.  He didn't describe the statistical basis for his opinion, but my reading of the political zeitgeist has me convinced that he has underestimated the anger and frustration consuming the democratic party's liberal base.  47% of Democrats believe President Obama should face a primary challenge in the 2012 elections.





I believe that if Obama had been on the ticket this year the democratic turnout would have been much worse.  The young people who worked so hard for Obama's election in 2008, the old left and the aging hippies who thought that they had finally reached the promised land, all stayed away from the polls in droves because they were simply sick and tired of being repeatedly lied to by the Obama Administration.  

Over the past two years the Obama Administration has
  • continued the most draconian Bush Administration privacy and soul destroying "war on terror" policies including the renewal of the Patriot Act and the shifting of the unholy rendition program from outsourced torture by foreign countries to the Iraqi and Afghani governments' torture chambers; 
  • continued to fight tooth and nail in the Federal courts to preserve the military's discriminatory "don't ask don't tell policy" barring gays from service in the armed forces; 
  • shelved any meaningful effort at comprehensive immigration reform and abdicated the immigration reform debate to kooks and racists; 
  • continued prosecuting State law sanctioned dispensaries and individual users of medical marijuana under Federal drug laws; 
  • failed to even initiate the promised closing of the Guantanamo Bay concentration camp; 
  • allowed the greedy one-percenter bastards from the major financial services companies - who were allowed to run amok during the Bush Administration - to gang rape small business and the American middle class and repeatedly pillage the public treasury; 
  • delegated the writing of his "signature" health care legilsation to Congressional Democrats and then abandoned the "public option" at the drop of a hat, thereby abandoning Americans to the whims of the insurance companies; 
  • engaged on a regular basis in the same unethical cronyism that has corrupted American politics for generations (including the targeting of Republican-owned auto dealerships for closure during the bailout of the auto industry, and the granting of numerous exceptions to the strict new anti-lobbyist policy on Executive Branch appointments);
  • granted exemptions to four countries from a Federal law that  bars U.S. Military assistance to nations that use child soldiers.
  • delayed the deadline for beginning the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Afghanaistan by four years, breaking perhaps his most important campaign promise.
      And on and on and on with example after example after example of the inconvenient truth that President Obama has broken nearly every major campaign promise that was supposed to set his Administration apart from the mistakes of the Bush Administration. There has been a lot of hope and very little change.