"Which is worse? The wolf who cries before eating the lamb or the wolf who does not."— Leo Tolstoy

Showing posts with label FIRST AMENDMENT. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FIRST AMENDMENT. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 29, 2012

#WHERE WAS TWITTER? DON'T LOOK UP.


There was a hearing this morning on a motion to quash a subpoena issued to Twitter by the Manhattan District Attorney's Office.  The subpoena seeks the tweets of a single  Occupy Wall Street protester who was arrested during the Brooklyn Bridge protest on October 1st. The Manhattan DA's subpoena asks for 30 days of tweets for the period before and after the arrest. This is the only subpoena issued to Twitter for tweets by any of the 900 protesters in the largest mass arrest in New York history. Why pick on this one guy?  Apparently, it is because while he was waiting in the police van, wondering where he was going and when he would be released, he tweeted the following:  "Help!  I am being kidnapped by armed thugs."  Someone in the NYPD has very thin skin.

The Manhattan DA had filed a response to NLG lawyer Marty Stolar's motion arguing that neither Stolar, nor his client, had standing to object to the subpoena since it only sought public tweets, The big question of the day came from New York County Criminal Court judge Neil Ross who asked the prosecutor "where is Twitter?"  This resulted in a mild burst of applause by the OWS defendants, and a moderate burst of anger from the courtroom  deputies, who told everyone to be quite or they would be removed from the courtroom. The no applause order was immediately met with a loud burst of applause from a very large man in the back row.  He was quickly escorted out of the courtroom.  This commotion was immediately followed by a woman who stood up and thanked Judge Ross for asking the  question "where is Twitter?"  She was quickly escorted out of  the courtroom

Getting back to the business at hand, Judge Ross asked, in mild amazement, why there wasn't a lawyer present to represent a corporation that was a party to a contested subpoena? Mr. Stolar informed the court that Twitter does not take a position on motions to quash subpoenas for information about customer accounts. Twitter apparently doesn't care who is able to rummage around in your tweets and clearly doesn't care what happens to your tweets after they have been tweeted.  

Kettled Occupy Wall Street Protestors Being Squeezed, Like a Tube of Tooth Past into Waiting Trucks

Sunday, October 23, 2011

The Meme as News - The "Mystery" of the 'Hipster Cop' - NYTimes Portrays 1st Precinct Censor as the Hipster Andy Griffith of Zuccotti Park.



Community Affairs Detective Eric Lee is a real charmer, but I'm not sure I'd call the lanky Bill Gates look-a-like  a "hipster," as The New York Times did last week in a puffy profile that focused on the Detective's wardrobe and his engaging ability to relate with the protestors encamped in Zuccotti park. As the Times described Detective Lee's musings about his impending retirement, "he looked out over Zuccotti Park from a familiar spot on the perimeter and said, 'Maybe I’ll grow my hair long again and join these guys.'

The Times profile was a follow-up on the Internet buzz created by the Gothamist and other blogs fascinated by the fact that Detective Lee doesn't wear black see-through socks and  cheap suits. The Hipster Cop meme flew through the new media sausage grinder appearing in The Atlantic's  Wire, the Huffington Post, The Washington Post, The Daily Beast  NPR and just about every other website that is read by more than two people. "It's my job [] to be the liaison between the precinct and the community we serve," Lee told a writer from GQ.  "I am who I am.  This is how I always dress. . . . Though maybe I'll wear a top hat to work tomorrow." 

Community Affairs Detective Lee is a real smoothie smooth when it comes to fostering community-police relations.  On September 29th I attended the 1st Precinct's Community Council meeting where I had a chance to see the "hipster cop" in action as he rudely informed a member of the public that no photographs could be taken during the meeting,   As  I remember, he was wearing a pink button-down shirt under a dark cardigan sweater that was two sizes too small, making the otherwise lean Detective look a bit chubby. Perhaps that was the reason for the ban on photography.   Detective Lee's behavior at the Community Council meeting was consistent with the video montage put together by Sparrow Media, documenting his overbearing demeanor when dealing with protestors.

I first noticed Detective Lee when he shouted at a citizen who was about to take a picture with his phone.  "Hey, buddy! Yeah, you! No photos," the "hipster cop" commanded in a  deep voice, punctuated by a Brooklyn  accent, that resonated with the confidence of someone who had been asserting his authority over other people for the past two decades. His entire demeanor was that  of an aggressive, but poorly disguised undercover narc . 

When the offending citizen asked him who he was, he identified himself as Community Affairs Detective Lee.  Detective Lee was asked what police regulation prohibited the taking of photographs during a public Community Council meeting, which is described as a "public forum" on the  Council's website. Detective Lee responded, in true hipster style, "it''s my regulation, that's all you need to know." Somehow, that is exactly the kind of response I would have expected from an NYPD Community Affairs Officer. 

What I didn't expect to see was a gushing GQ fashion spread and  an "aw shucks," warm and cuddly New York Times profile on this guy, making him out to be the hipster Andy Griffith of Zuccotti Park.

The online phenomenon of the "Hipster Cop" demonstrates the danger of new media treating memes as news, other than being newsworthy as a meme.  Memes can travel faster than a European virus through an indigenous population.  It often takes time for the reality to catch up to the memery, and by then the footprint of the original meme has already left an indelible impression on the cyber landscape.

The only "mystery" about the "hipster cop" is why the reporters from the NYC  dailies don't know who the Precinct Community Affairs Officers are and why they don't attend Precinct Community Council meetings.  The only solace I can find in this revolting new media love-fest is that Detective Lee's colleagues are probably making his life miserable with constant ribbing over all the attention being given to the "hipster cop."


Wednesday, October 5, 2011

How To Protest In New York City | Mike Cane's xBlog

How To Protest In New York City | Mike Cane's xBlog:
"First of all, recognize that you are going up against the NYPD.
The NYPD mainly doesn’t live in New York City. They come from Long Island. They hate New York City. And they basically act like any occupying army does. And they hate protests. Although a protest can generate overtime, it keeps them away from their families and upsets their schedules. You are not a “duty calls” emergency. You are an annoyance. So they have even more reason to hate your ass."
This hadn't really occurred to me before, but I think Mike Caine might be right.  

Sunday, October 2, 2011

Advocacy 101: When You're on a Roll Don't Try to Change The Message or The Image

This item is from the Occupy Wall Street Calendar of Events for Monday, October 3rd:
 Everyone come dressed as a corporate zombie! This means jacket and tie if possible, white face, fake blood, eating monopoly money, and doing a slow march, so when people come to work on Monday in this neighborhood they see us reflecting the metaphor of their actions. Tell your friends, Facebook it, Twitter it, and it can be MJ Thriller-style too! Create a different image than police brutality!
As far as images go, I think the image to go for is  more Susan B. Anthony or Martin Luther King than Wavy Gravy.  Do they not realize that the September 24h protest - including the videos of the police assaulting peaceful protestors - is the catalyst that is in the process of transforming their movement into a major media event.  The message should be about police brutality and free expression.  Don't run from it, embrace it, use it and change it.

Although I must admit it would be pretty cool - as I am sure Eric Cartman would agree -  to see zombies being arrested and beaten on Wall Street if you didn't realize there were creative young people underneath the makeup.

Friday, September 30, 2011

Former NYPD Internal Affairs Division Investigator and now Deputy Inspector Anthony Bologna is an embarrassment to Commissioner Kelly and will likely be forced to retire.

My experience, after nearly twenty years of advocacy involving law-enforcement issues, is that police departments can weather a lot of criticism without having to reform bad police practices.  Their resolve starts to crumble when they are subject to widespread ridicule, humiliation and embarrassment.  It was therefore a good sign for the Occupy Wall Street protestors when The Daily Show's John Stewart devoted a lengthy 6-minute segment to commentary and a parody of Deputy Inspector Anthony Bologna's unprovoked macings of peaceful protestors on September 24th:



Once your actions start to embarrass the Police Commissioner it's time to begin planning for your retirement. I am doubling down on my earlier prediction that Deputy Inspector Bologna will likely elect to  retire before the end of the year.

According to a profile of Deputy Inspector Anthony Bologna published in Community Media's Downtown Express when he assumed command of the 1st Precinct in  1005, he was once an investigator in the Internal Affairs Division:
“It was my first taste of internal investigation and it opened my eyes to the darker side of police work,” Bologna said. “You read in the papers about cops doing things that you can’t believe because you think everybody’s like you. But a department this large can’t really be completely free of it. If you don’t find anything wrong, you’re in real trouble because you’re not looking.
I'm sure the IAD Detectives who will be investigating Anthony Bologna will be taking that advice to heart.  Bologna was also quoted in the profile as saying that he didn't think he could work in the early 1970s pre-Knapp Commission NYPD.  Apparently, macing peaceful female protestors, and then leaving them to writhe in agony without medical attention, must have been considered sissy stuff in the pre-Knapp NYPD.

The profile in the Downtown Express does not paint a picture of an out of control cop but someone with a stellar record who deserves to be admired.  If his statements about police wrongdoing and not being able to work in a corrupt Department are sincere you have to ask what happened between 2005 and the now infamous video of Bologna's multiple macing of peaceful  protestors.

Something must have happened because in July 2010 the Downtown Express reported that Bologna was removed as the  commanding officer of the First Precinct and replaced with Deputy Inspector Edward J. Winski.  Deputy Inspector Bologna was assigned to "Special Projects" in the Manhattan South Borough Command.

“Change is always interesting,” Bologna told the local news website DNAinfo when the transfer was announced. “You do what they give you and you do your best. I’m looking forward to new challenges.”

Although DNAinfo made the unsourced claim that NYPD precinct commanders rarely stay as long as as Bologna did, I still get the feeling from his comnents that it wasn't a voluntary transfer, particularly since he didn't receive a promotion in rank.  "Interesting" is the kind of adjective you use when you are trying to be polite about the turd you were just served while dining at your father-in-law's restaurant.  

DNAinfo made the unsourced claim that Bologna was "well-liked" within the precinct, but "Special Projects" sounds like a duty title reserved for fup's who are coasting to retirement.  I could very well be wrong about this but Bologna, who became a police officer at the relatively old age of 27, only had one or two more years until he would qualify for a thirty year pension.  It seems odd they wouldn't let him finish out his career as commander of the 1st Precinct.

We will know that Deputy Inspector Bologna is about to be thrown to the wolves if negative information about him starts to leak to mainstream press like the Times, the News and the Post.  The likelier scenario is that he will be allowed to retire quietly. 

I met Deputy Inspector Winski last night at the 1st Precinct's monthly Community Council meeting where I expressed my dissatisfaction with NYPD's performance during the September 24th protests.  There were a lot of people in attendance, including a number of Occupy Wall Street folks who were extremely conciliatory almost to the point of being apologetic for having been arrested, beaten and maced on September 24th.  It seems non-confrontational pacifism is the name of the game for the Occupy Wall Street protestors. They are the polar opposite of a Seattle-violence style anarchist protest movement.

As I expected, I was greeted with a polite but mostly frosty reception by the Community Council, which is essentially a local chamber of commerce police department booster organization. Yet the community Council's and Neighborhood Community Board's are very politically influential and City Council staff usually attends the meetings.

More on the community counsel meeting and the machinations of the precinct's Community Affairs Detectives meeting in a few hours.
Volume 18 • Issue 5 | JUNE 24- 2, 20New captain busted pushers, gangsters and cops
Downtown Express photo by Elisabeth Robert
First Precinct Captain Anthony Bologna went to college to become a teacher, but budget cuts led him to the police force.  
By Albert Amateau
In his 23 years with the N.Y.P.D., Captain Anthony Bologna, the new commanding officer of Lower Manhattan’s First Precinct, has been all over Manhattan and much of Brooklyn.
He’s been a SNEU (Street Narcotics Enforcement Unit) cop busting drug pushers, served in Manhattan South in an anti-drunk-driving squad, worked in the Brooklyn South Task Force in the early 1990s during the Crown Heights riot, investigated police officers involved with drug dealers in the Internal Affairs Unit, served in the Organized Crime Control Bureau, led a detective squad in Washington Heights that closed a dozen murder cases one year, and served as commanding officer of the Manhattan South Task Force just before assuming command of the First Precinct at the end of last month.
“One thing about police work in this city, it’s all about change,” he told a visitor last week. “With me there’s really been a lot of change and I love it—most of my changes have come because of promotions,” he said.  
A native and resident of Staten Island with his family (wife, two grown daughters and a son, 13), Bologna also serves in the U.S. Coast Guard Reserve with a rank of chief petty officer as a “sea marshal” inspecting ships that come into New York Harbor. He earned a B.S. from John Jay College in 1990 and in June of 1998 completed the program for law enforcement professionals at the FBI National Academy.

Bologna, 51, became a policeman relatively late in life.  
“I was 27, married and owned a deli in Staten Island,” he recalled. He started at C.C.N.Y. as a 20-year-old hoping to become a teacher, but in the mid 1970s, the city was in the midst of a fiscal crisis and was laying off teachers. Bologna had worked part time in a Port Richmond, S.I., deli and decided to stay with it, eventually buying out the owner.  
“But I always wanted to be a police officer,” he said. Cops who came into the deli would encourage him to take the test, which he did in 1982, a year that the city was recovering economically. The Police Academy took 3,000 cadets that year.  
Bologna’s first assignment was in the Seventh Precinct on Pitt St. on the Lower East Side. Manhattan South Borough Command at the time was in the same building, and Bologna and a partner were assigned by the command to make D.W.I. arrests of drunk drivers. The offenses were frequent and often blatant. “Drivers would stop and ask us directions with cans of beer in their hands,” he recalled.  
Bologna next went to SNEU units in the Seventh and then the Ninth Precincts, both on Downtown’s East Side. “We’d climb up fire escapes to the roofs with binoculars for observation. It put me in the middle of the narcotics enforcement street scene,” he said. In January, 1988, he transferred to the Organized Crime Control Bureau, working again on narcotics enforcement, “at a more interesting level,” he said. 
He moved to the 76th Precinct in Brooklyn in 1989 as a sergeant and then went to Brooklyn’s 72nd Precinct. His career then took him to the Brooklyn South Task Force where he was on duty during the boycott of Korean grocery stores by black activists in 1990 and the Crown Heights riots in 1992.  
“It was a rough period. Buildings burned, rocks were being thrown. I got the feeling that nothing would ever be the same again. But it took a while to see that it wasn’t nearly as bad as it looked,” he said.  
In Feb. 1993 he began working as an internal investigator in the Chief of Patrol’s office. “It was my first taste of internal investigation and it opened my eyes to the darker side of police work,” Bologna said. “You read in the papers about cops doing things that you can’t believe because you think everybody’s like you. But a department this large can’t really be completely free of it. If you don’t find anything wrong, you’re in real trouble because you’re not looking.”  
“I don’t think I could work in the pre-Knapp [before the Knapp Commission investigations] days in the early ‘70s,” he said. In the past, service in Internal Affairs was held in low esteem. “But it is now a career path,” Bologna observed. When officers go before promotion review boards, representatives of all divisions are present, but Internal Affairs has the first option on candidates.  
Promoted to lieutenant in 1996, he went back to the Lower East Side’s Seventh Precinct. He became a detective the next year and was appointed head of the squad in the 30th Precinct in Washington Heights, two years after the “Dirty 30” corruption scandal shook up the precinct. There were 18 homicides in 1997, all but four or five of which were solved, and 12 homicides in 1998, which were all solved, Bologna recalled.    
But his career path changed again when he passed the exam for captain and won the promotion in October, 1998 that sent him back to Manhattan South Borough Command. He became acting commanding officer in February 2000 of the command’s Task Force, the unit that responds to special situations like demonstrations and received the full appointment in May the following year.
On May 30, 2005, Bologna was name C.O. of the First Precinct. “Getting the command of a precinct is the real test of a career officer,” said Bologna, “It’s a big responsibility and doesn’t leave me much time to do things like scuba diving, but I love it.” 

Thursday, September 29, 2011

Daily Kos: Occupy Wall Street: Manhattan DA to investigate use of pepper spray on demonstrators

Daily Kos: Occupy Wall Street: NYPD and Manhattan DA to investigate use of pepper spray on demonstrators:

"At the same time, the office of the Manhattan district attorney, Cyrus R. Vance Jr., has opened an investigation into the episode, which was captured on video and disseminated on the Internet, according to a person briefed on the matter who spoke on the condition of anonymity because the inquiry is continuing."

First Hand Account of Woman Pepper Sprayed: Occupy Wall Street September 24th Anthony Bologna Macing Incident

This is an excellent first hand report from the Boston Review by Jeanne Mansfield, one of the women maced by Deputy Inspector Bologna.  

It seems she was a tourist visiting from out of town with her boyfriend and they received a very special greeting from the NYPD's welcome wagon. It gives  some context to the events that I didn't have before from any of the "bona fide" press reports.  The account of the beat downs of the African American man described in her article - and of the videographer who had the audacity to film the assault and ask for his name - is consistent with the "marching orders" I witnessed.  No one was being allowed to question the police.   The supervisors were all acting like Eric Cartman in South Park's "Die Hippie Die" episode.  
  
From Mansfield's article:
  . . . There was an anger in those white-shirt’s eyes that said, “You don’t matter.” And whether they were just scared or irrational or looking for a target for their rage, there was no excuse for their abuse of authority. 
  . . . it becomes clear that the white-shirts are a different species. We need to get out of there.
. . . A woman with two little girls in tow walks up to a cop at the end of the block and explains that they just need to get to ballet, but he won’t let them through. The woman seems to accept this, turns to the girls, thinks for a second, then marches straight to the edge of the fence at the corner of the building. A different officer sees them coming and, understanding their situation, lets them through. So Frank and I bolt for the same opening and escape.
. . . I had always thought that people who complained about police brutality must have done something to provoke it, that surely cops wouldn’t hurt people without a really good reason. But they do. We were on the curb, we were contained, we were unarmed. Pepper spray hurts like hell, and the experience only makes me wish I’d done something more to deserve it.  

Speech and Spatial Tactics by Professor Timothy Zick

    

This is a very insightful article that should be used as a blue print for  litigators crafting arguments in First Amendment cases involving  restrictions on protest demonstrations.

Professor Timothy Zick, Speech  and Spatial Tactics, Texas  Law Review.
Volume  84,  Number  3, at pp. 581-582 (February  2006) (footnotes omitted):
"It is a serious mistake to view place as merely an inert container or a backdrop for expressive scenes. Place can be a powerful weapon of social and political control. Today speech, including core political speech, is being disciplined, controlled, and even suppressed through a variety of spatial techniques. Consider the following recent examples:
1: the free speech cage, an architecture of mesh fabric, coiled razor wire, chain-link fences, and jersey barriers, constructed to contain protesters at the 2004 Democratic National Convention;

2: the "steel cocoon" that emerged within the District of Columbia prior to the 2005 presidential inauguration,

3: the confinement of protesters to spaces behind bleachers and fenced-in areas more than 100 feet from the inauguration parade route; 
4: the 25 block "restricted zone" that prohibited all protests near the 1999 World Trade Organization meetings in Seattle; 
5: the 1/2 block "frozen zone" or "bubble" used to shield New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg from union members protesting at the 2004 Republican National Convention;
6: the use of metal barricades, or "pens," to confine and control those protesting the Iraq War; 7: statutory and injunctive "free speech" and "speech-free" zones erected around abortion clinics and various other public accommodations;  
8: campus "free speech zones" that confine First Amendment activity to narrowly circumscribed places;  9: recent laws in several states establishing protest zones for antiwar speech near funerals.
Under current First Amendment doctrine, restrictions on the place where expression may occur are routinely upheld. The First Amendment nominally requires that these sorts of restrictions, like content-neutral restrictions on the time and manner of expression, satisfy an "intermediate" level of scrutiny. But in truth this standard is little more than a weak strain of rationality review. Courts generally tend to view spatial restrictions as unrelated to expressive content. They are treated as inarguably rational means of serving governmental interests such as maintaining order and security. And, indeed, some such regulations are necessary to preserve a minimal degree of order. Parade routes, for instance, must sometimes be altered to account for such realities as traffic and pedestrian flow. The First Amendment is not a license to speak wherever one pleases. But this basic principle does not afford the state plenary authority to suppress speech on matters of political and social import by significantly displacing or confining it. Purportedly neutral restrictions on place can and do cancel expressive and associative rights. . . . 

Tuesday, November 30, 2010

WikiLeaks Cable Viewer

Cable Viewer:
"The cables show the extent of US spying on its allies and the UN; turning a blind eye to corruption and human rights abuse in 'client states'; backroom deals with supposedly neutral countries; lobbying for US corporations; and the measures US diplomats take to advance those who have access to them.
This document release reveals the contradictions between the US’s public persona and what it says behind closed doors – and shows that if citizens in a democracy want their governments to reflect their wishes, they should ask to see what’s going on behind the scenes.
Every American schoolchild is taught that George Washington – the country’s first President – could not tell a lie. If the administrations of his successors lived up to the same principle, today’s document flood would be a mere embarrassment. Instead, the US Government has been warning governments -- even the most corrupt -- around the world about the coming leaks and is bracing itself for the exposures."